Skip to main content
Enterprise Agile Planning Image

This post is from the CollabNet VersionOne blog and has not been updated since the original publish date.

Last Updated Nov 18, 2007 — Enterprise Agile Planning expert

Analysis Paralysis

Enterprise Agile Planning

From the November 2007 issue of Fast Company:

[Researchers] gave doctors the medical history of a 67-year-old man who’d been suffering chronic hip pain from osteoarthritis. He’d been given drugs to treat his pain, but they had been ineffective, so there was only one viable option: hip-replacement surgery, which would involve a long and painful recovery. Then a final check with the pharmacy uncovered one medication that hadn’t been tried. Would the doctors like to give the drug a shot? 47% of doctors chose to try the medication in a final attempt to keep the patient from going under the knife.

Another group of doctors saw the same facts, except they were told that the pharmacy had discovered two medications that hadn’t yet been tried…. only 28% chose to try either one.

(The article goes on to advocate simplified strategies such as “We don’t want to be first but we sure as hell don’t want to be third.”)

What’s going on here? Did reluctance to make a decision block any action to prevent surgery?

“Dammit Jim, I’m an engineer, not a doctor.”

Do you find yourself spinning in circles over design decisions and business priorities? Perhaps analysis paralysis is perfectly natural because human nature is optimized for a simpler life. We certainly see this with our clients.

Scrum’s insistence on demonstrating a potentially-shippable product increment every Sprint encourages teams to make a choice. The two-week to 30-day Sprint length is a kind of circuit breaker on analysis paralysis. Don’t expect a perfect choice. Do your analysis through exploratory action. Often making a mistake is the fastest way to find out what the right choice may have been.

Download the PDF version: Analysis Paralysis blog

More from the Blog

View more
Apr 08, 2021

Making IT services more agile

Enterprise Agile Planning
The agile revolution completely transformed how we create digital prod ...
Read More
Feb 14, 2021

Reflecting on the 20th anniversary of the Agile Manifesto

Enterprise Agile Planning
Over the past 20 years, it’s been amazing to watch an idea from ...
Read More
Feb 08, 2021

How does agile apply to an entire organization?

Enterprise Agile Planning
Before we dive into the main subject of this blog post, it is importan ...
Read More
Feb 03, 2021

It took a pandemic to realize why digital transformation actually matters

Enterprise Agile Planning
Before anyone had ever heard of COVID-19, businesses across the globe ...
Read More
Contact Us