Skip to main content
Enterprise Agile Planning Image

This post is from the CollabNet VersionOne blog and has not been updated since the original publish date.

Last Updated Sep 11, 2008 — Enterprise Agile Planning expert

Is open-source "difficult"?

Enterprise Agile Planning


Has Matt Asay lost his way? In a post with a title about managing an open-source community, built up of comments about patching an open source project, and ending with a complaint about how hard it all is, he uncharacteristically never touches the actual question of community. Open-source projects are community works, not baskets for drive-by
contribution, little falling-away jump shot-patches. Open-source folk
like to call themselves a "meritocracy," and there’s a lot of truth to
that, but what you really need to advance in an open-source community
is contribution: your merit has to be shown by strengthening the community, not just lobbing code-bombs over the ridge.


Still, while community membership requires more than "casual contribution," you shouldn’t have to "become a key member."  You should make a reasonable effort to match coding styles and other conventions of the project. You should be prepared to discuss your changes with some more plugged-in member, for clarifications and alternatives. You should hang around long enough to see your changes make it into a release, and confirm that they work as you expected. And you should be prepared to help others learn the community ropes, at least for a while.

The Subversion project’s "Hacker’s Guide to Subversion" strikes a pretty reasonable balance:

If you just want to file bugs–or even patches–and have someone else deal with the rest, you’re thinking in paid-support terms. For the most interesting open-source projects, you can find that easily enough. Here at CollabNet, we’re happy to provide that service for Subversion
users. Indeed, we do the same thing routinely for customers of all our
products, representing their needs into the communities of the many
open-source projects whose work we use. But it’s something separate from the core of open-source, which is the community.


More from the Blog

View more
Apr 08, 2021

Making IT services more agile

Enterprise Agile Planning
The agile revolution completely transformed how we create digital prod ...
Read More
Feb 14, 2021

Reflecting on the 20th anniversary of the Agile Manifesto

Enterprise Agile Planning
Over the past 20 years, it’s been amazing to watch an idea from ...
Read More
Feb 08, 2021

How does agile apply to an entire organization?

Enterprise Agile Planning
Before we dive into the main subject of this blog post, it is importan ...
Read More
Feb 03, 2021

It took a pandemic to realize why digital transformation actually matters

Enterprise Agile Planning
Before anyone had ever heard of COVID-19, businesses across the globe ...
Read More
Contact Us